Doug Johnstone
Orenda Books, 12 September 2024
Available as: PB, 276pp, audio, e
Source: Advance copy
ISBN(PB): 9781916788268
I'm grateful to Orenda Books for sending me a copy of Living is a Problem to consider for review, and to Anne for inviting me to join the book's blogtour.
Living is a Problem sees the Skelf women - grandmother Dorothy, mother and daughter Jenny and granddaughter Hannah - perhaps face their toughest trial yet in this series. And if you've been following the brilliant #SkelfSummer recap of the previous 5 books, you'll know that's saying something.
The challenges that confront the three here don't arise, at least not directly, from perplexing mysteries. If you've read any of the earlier Skelf books you'll know that the family are undertakers in Edinburgh, but also private investigators. Naturally, the latter role can create complex scenarios to unravel, and there are some of those here. The funeral of an Edinburgh gangster, disrupted by parties unknown. The grave of a child disturbed. A missing woman, a refugee from Ukraine.
For once though, these cases are "solved" fairly straightforwardly. There isn't a lot of subtle detecting. But in these books, and never more so that in Living is a Problem, just establishing the facts is only the beginning. The harder part of the Skelfs' work only begins after that. The cases aren't really "solved" till parties are reconciled; difficult decisions made; compromises reached. Because it's not really about the crime, it's about the opposite of crime, to paraphrase the title of the last book, The Opposite of Lonely. Peace is not the same as the absence of war. How will the networks of people affected by all these events learn to live with themselves - and with each other - after what's come out?
That question hangs heavy over Living is a Problem from the start. The Skelfs, and their associates - Archie, Brodie, Thomas - still have to reckon with the events of the earlier books. Dorothy's and Thomas's relationship has been particularly strained after the dangers and violence in The Opposite of Lonely. Thomas has taken things hard. The antagonists in that book, corrupt police Webster and Low, have been taken down, but continue to exert a malign influence. Hannah, knowing that her father was a wrong'un, still mourns him and the life that she and Jenny might have had if he had been a decent man. It's complicated. Living is a problem, as Scottish band Biffy Clyro sang, Because Everything Dies. To which I might oppose Bruce Springsteen singing Everything dies, baby, that's a fact, But maybe everything that dies some day comes back. (Sorry, I am going to work The Boss into any review I can, of course I am).
To be less oblique, the funeral side of the Skelf business might seem like the last word in finality - what is more final than death - but this book teases the idea that due to our interrelatedness, death is not the end. A dead child affects the living, and how we deal with the death may be important. Or how we fail to deal with it. Death has a way of fossilising, of sanctifying, from Old Dead White Guy statues in Edinburgh which belie the deeds of those men (they are always men) to the trouble of living with the legacy of a war hero in the family to dealing with unacknowledged grief.
And that is really the essence of the Skelf books. It may be convenient to see them as crime fiction, because I'm not sure there's a label for what they really are - moral fiction? human fiction? Something like that? Whatever it is has at its heart the wonderfulness and the sadness of being human and the need to be on the side of those in need. That's what the Skelfs are about and long may they continue it.
For more information about Living is a Problem, see the publisher's website here - and of course the other stops on the blogtour which you can see listed on the poster below.
You can buy Living is a Problem from your local high street bookshop or online from Bookshop UK, Hive Books, Blackwell's, Foyle's, WH Smith or Waterstones. Other online retailers are available.
Thanks for the blog tour support x
ReplyDelete